Archived 2022-10-11. Content moved to CDS Guide, Data formats - schemas.
Question
Can you please confirm the Voluntary and Required Product data referred to in the Consumer Data Right Rules is NOT the same as the fields shown as Mandatory and Optional in the Consumer Data Standard? i.e. all data items in the Data Standard are Required Product Data and Voluntary Product data refers to additional fields or APIs that Data Holders can decide to add if they wish.
Answer
That is correct. Voluntary and Required Product Data referred to in the CDR Rules is NOT the same as the fields shown as Mandatory and Optional in the Data Standard.
Required product data are data clusters which must be disclosed by a data holder pursuant to a valid product data request. Voluntary product data are data clusters which may be disclosed by a data holder pursuant to a valid product data request. Clause 3.1 in Schedule 3 of the CDR Rules defines required product data and voluntary product data.
On the other hand, mandatory and optional fields in the data standards are fields which respectively must and may have a non-null value. For example, where the standard has a mandatory field, data holders are required to share that field, but where they do not have the data it must be represented as a default value or an empty value as applicable.
In brief, the data cluster language in the rules relates to the type of data which may or must be disclosed by a data holder; while the mandatory/optional fields language in the standards relates to the parameters for the APIs used to request and disclose CDR data.
Comments
4 comments
It would be helpful if the items in all the product data schemas that are "Required Product data" were labelled as such.
I don't think there are any 'Voluntary' items defined in the current CDS schemas, which would mean that all fields are 'Required product data', subject to being mandatory or optional in the payload as detailed in the answer above (mandatory must be non-null and present in the payload, optional may be null or not present where the item is not applicable or not available.)
More details for reference -
https://consumerdatastandardsaustralia.github.io/standards/#mandatory-optional-fields
https://consumerdatastandardsaustralia.github.io/standards/#empty-null-fields
I agree however it appears not everyone has interpreted it his way.
Nils' interpretation is correct.
Required data is the data that is designated (which are the fields in the standards). Voluntary data is extension that bank may wish to make available to improve customer value or even to monetise.
As this data is entirely discretionary no standard can be made for it by the DSB.
Please sign in to leave a comment.